Concrete patio or wood deck for your Minnesota home? Compare upfront costs, 20-year maintenance, durability, and resale value to make the right choice.
.png)
You're standing in your backyard, envisioning the perfect outdoor living space. Maybe it's hosting summer barbecues, watching kids play, or simply enjoying your morning coffee outside. But you're facing a common Minnesota homeowner dilemma: should you build a concrete patio or install a wood deck?
This isn't a simple preference question. The choice between a concrete patio and a deck affects your initial investment, ongoing maintenance costs, long-term durability in Minnesota's harsh climate, and ultimately your home's resale value.
Here's what most homeowners discover: while decks and patios have similar upfront costs, their 20-year total cost of ownership tells a dramatically different story. And in Minnesota's brutal freeze-thaw climate, durability differences become even more pronounced.
The short answer? For most Minnesota homeowners, a quality concrete patio delivers superior long-term value. But let's break down exactly why with real numbers, honest comparisons, and climate-specific considerations.
We're Preferred 1 Concrete, and we've been building concrete patios, driveways, and hardscaping features throughout Minneapolis-St. Paul since 2004. My father's been in concrete since the 1980s, so we've seen how different outdoor surfaces perform over decades of Minnesota weather.
We created this comprehensive comparison because we want you to make an informed decision based on facts, not just initial sticker shock. We're obviously in the concrete business, so yes, we're hoping you'll choose a patio. But we're confident that once you understand the true costs and benefits, you'll see why concrete makes sense for Minnesota homes.
If you decide a deck is right for you, we respect that. But if the numbers and logic point you toward concrete, we'd love the opportunity to create a beautiful patio that transforms your backyard into a destination.
Now let's dig into the real comparison.
Pressure-treated pine deck: $15-$25 per square foot installed
Cedar deck: $25-$35 per square foot installed
Composite deck (Trex, TimberTech): $30-$45 per square foot installed
Premium hardwood (Ipe, Tigerwood): $35-$55 per square foot installed
Typical 12x20 deck (240 sq ft) costs:
Typical 16x20 deck (320 sq ft) costs:
Standard broom finish: $8-$12 per square foot installed
Colored concrete: $10-$14 per square foot installed
Stamped concrete: $12-$18 per square foot installed
Exposed aggregate: $12-$16 per square foot installed
Typical 12x20 patio (240 sq ft) costs:
Typical 16x20 patio (320 sq ft) costs:
For comparable quality levels, concrete patios typically cost 20-40% less than decks initially. A standard broom-finish concrete patio costs significantly less than even a basic pressure-treated deck, while a premium stamped concrete patio costs less than a composite deck.
However, initial cost is only the beginning of the story.
Initial installation is just the first expense. Let's calculate the true 20-year cost including all maintenance and repairs.
Initial installation: $3,600-$6,000
Ongoing maintenance:
20-year total cost: $11,760-$21,440
Initial installation: $7,200-$10,800
Ongoing maintenance:
20-year total cost: $11,300-$18,800
Initial installation: $1,920-$2,880
Ongoing maintenance:
20-year total cost: $2,770-$5,280
Initial installation: $2,880-$4,320
Ongoing maintenance:
20-year total cost: $4,820-$9,120
The shocking reality:
This is the hidden truth deck companies don't advertise: What looks like a modest price difference becomes a massive cost gap over time.
Minnesota's weather is uniquely brutal on outdoor structures. Let's examine how each material handles our specific challenges.
How it affects decks:
How it affects concrete:
Winner: Concrete (by a huge margin)
How it affects decks:
How it affects concrete:
Winner: Concrete (no contest)
Deck considerations:
Concrete considerations:
Winner: Concrete
How it affects decks:
How it affects concrete:
Winner: Slight edge to concrete (both fade, but concrete doesn't require regular treatment)
Deck considerations:
Concrete considerations:
Winner: Depends on color choices, but light concrete wins
Concrete patios are specifically engineered to thrive in Minnesota's climate. Decks, even with premium materials, are constantly battling against it.
Beyond dollar costs, consider the time investment required.
Annual tasks:
Every 2-3 years:
Total deck maintenance over 20 years: 200-300 hours
At even $25/hour value of your time, that's $5,000-$7,500 in labor costs not captured in the financial analysis above.
Annual tasks:
Every 3-5 years:
Total concrete maintenance over 20 years: 50-75 hours
At $25/hour, that's $1,250-$1,875—less than one-quarter the time investment of a deck.
Even if you hire professionals for everything, concrete maintenance costs dramatically less than deck maintenance.
One argument for decks is design flexibility. Let's examine this honestly.
Elevation: Decks excel at creating outdoor spaces on sloped lots or elevated off the ground (second-story decks, hillside decks)
Multi-level designs: Decks can incorporate steps, multiple levels, and built-in seating relatively easily
Railing options: Extensive railing styles available (wood, metal, cable, glass)
Natural wood aesthetic: Some people prefer the natural wood look (though this requires constant maintenance to preserve)
Size and shape flexibility: Concrete can be formed into virtually any shape—curves, circles, irregular organic shapes—without structural limitations
Surface finish options:
Color options: Integral colors (throughout concrete) or topical stains in virtually unlimited colors
Seamless integration: Can easily integrate concrete patios with retaining walls, stairs, fire pit pads, and other hardscaping
Built-in features: Can incorporate planters, seating walls, fire pit surrounds directly into the patio
Modern aesthetic: Contemporary concrete finishes create sleek, sophisticated outdoor spaces that appeal to modern design preferences
Choose a deck if: Your lot requires elevation (walkout basement, hillside), you want a second-story outdoor space, or you specifically love the wood aesthetic and are willing to maintain it
Choose concrete if: You want ground-level outdoor living space, prefer low maintenance, like modern aesthetics, or want extensive design flexibility in shape and finish
For most ground-level Twin Cities backyards, concrete offers more design options at lower cost.
How do patios and decks affect your home's resale value in the Minneapolis-St. Paul market?
According to Remodeling Magazine's Cost vs. Value Report:
Example: $10,000 composite deck might add $7,000-$8,000 to home value
However: This assumes the deck is in good condition at sale time. A 10-year-old deck showing wear significantly reduces return. A deck needing staining or repairs may actually hurt value.
Concrete patios typically recover 70-85% of installation costs at resale in the Twin Cities market.
Example: $6,000 stamped concrete patio might add $4,200-$5,100 to home value
Advantages:
Concrete patios consistently increase Twin Cities home values while requiring virtually no maintenance.
Here's what real estate agents know: a 10-year-old concrete patio in good condition (requiring only periodic sealing) is a selling point. A 10-year-old deck showing wear, needing staining, with some boards requiring replacement is a concern that often triggers price negotiations.
Winner: Concrete (better long-term value retention)
Minnesota families need to consider safety, especially with children and elderly family members.
Splinters: Even well-maintained wood decks develop splinters that can injure bare feet
Uneven surfaces: Warped boards create tripping hazards
Gaps between boards: Small toys, phones, and items fall through; children's fingers can get pinched
Railing failures: Improper installation or deteriorated connections can make railings unsafe
Rot hidden underneath: Structural rot in joists/posts can occur invisibly, creating collapse risk
Slippery when wet: Wet wood can be extremely slippery (worse than concrete)
Nail/screw pop-ups: Fasteners work loose over time, creating sharp protrusions
Even, stable surface: Properly installed concrete stays level and even
No gaps or protrusions: Smooth, continuous surface with no tripping hazards
Textured finishes: Broom-finished or stamped concrete provides excellent traction, even when wet
No rot-related collapse risk: Concrete doesn't deteriorate structurally
Crack control: Properly placed control joints manage cracking in straight lines (not random tripping hazards)
No splinters ever: Solid surface never splinters
Winner: Concrete (significantly safer, especially long-term)
To be fair, there are legitimate scenarios where a deck makes more sense:
If you have a walkout basement or hillside lot and want outdoor space at the upper level, a deck is your only practical option. Concrete patios work at ground level; decks excel at elevation.
Homes with upper-level doors leading to outdoor space need decks. Concrete doesn't work here.
If you genuinely love the natural wood look and are committed to maintaining it every 2-3 years, and budget allows for the ongoing costs, a deck might align better with your aesthetic preferences.
If you're planning to sell within 3-5 years and want maximum immediate curb appeal, a brand-new deck creates a "wow factor." (Though a beautiful stamped concrete patio does too, at lower cost.)
Deck construction is more DIY-friendly than concrete placement (though still requires significant skill for proper installation). If you have carpentry skills and time, a DIY deck might save money on labor.
For these specific scenarios, a deck can be the right choice. But for most ground-level Twin Cities outdoor living spaces, concrete delivers superior value.
We've presented the honest comparison. Now let's explain why choosing Preferred 1 Concrete for your patio makes sense.
We don't just pour concrete and hope it survives Minnesota winters. We engineer every patio specifically for our climate:
Proper air entrainment: We verify 5-7% air content in every load using ACI-certified testing procedures. This isn't optional—it's essential for freeze-thaw survival.
Adequate base preparation: We excavate properly, install 4-6 inches of compacted aggregate base, and ensure proper drainage. The foundation under your patio determines its 30-year performance.
Correct concrete strength: We use 4,000+ PSI concrete for patios (stronger than most contractors use). The extra cost is minimal; the durability benefit is substantial.
Optimal slope and drainage: Every patio slopes away from your home (1-2% grade minimum) to shed water immediately. We eliminate pooling water that causes freeze-thaw damage.
We've been installing concrete patios since 2004, and my father's been in concrete since the 1980s. We know exactly what Minnesota requires.
Most concrete contractors use ready-mix trucks from batch plants. The concrete starts curing the moment it's mixed, creating time pressure that can compromise quality.
We use a CemenTech C60 volumetric mixer that produces concrete on your property. Materials stay separate until the exact moment we need them, giving us:
This technology costs more to operate but delivers measurably better results. Your patio gets the best concrete possible, every single time.
We're ACI-certified concrete field-testing technicians and flatwork specialists. This certification means we're trained in:
Most residential concrete contractors don't have this certification. We do because we're committed to technical excellence, not just "good enough."
We don't build cookie-cutter patios. We create custom outdoor living spaces tailored to your vision:
Finish options:
Color options:
Shape flexibility:
Check out our portfolio to see the diverse patios we've created throughout the Twin Cities.
We know the contractor industry has a terrible reputation for communication. We're different.
We answer our phones. We show up when scheduled. We provide detailed written estimates. We keep you informed throughout your project. We treat you like a person, not just another job.
This shouldn't be revolutionary, but in the contractor world, it is. With Preferred 1 Concrete, professional communication is simply how we operate every day.
We serve Minneapolis, St. Paul, Lakeville, Burnsville, Eagan, Apple Valley, Prior Lake, Edina, Minnetonka, and throughout the South Metro and Twin Cities area. Wherever you are, we bring the same expertise and commitment to quality.
You now understand the true comparison between concrete patios and decks. You know that while initial costs are similar, the 20-year total cost of ownership strongly favors concrete. You understand why concrete performs better in Minnesota's harsh climate. And you've seen the maintenance time and money concrete saves.
If you're ready to move forward with a concrete patio, we'd love to help.
Contact Preferred 1 Concrete today for a comprehensive patio estimate. We'll visit your property, understand your vision, discuss finish and color options, and provide a detailed written estimate.
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
.png)
